The Best Residential Roofers
Lexington
Who do you trust to protect your home when your roof is all that stands between your loved ones and a raging storm?
When the rain is pounding, the wind is howling, and you are lying awake, wondering if that ceiling stain is about to turn into a real leak, who do you call in Lexington that you can truly trust?
Lexington is not just another small town; it is a historic community with deep roots, classic architecture, and homes that often have older rooflines, unique pitches, and details that require experienced craftsmanship.
And then there’s the weather. Living in the Shenandoah Valley, homeowners can face:
- Strong storms and wind-driven rain that test shingles and flashing
- Hot, humid summers can accelerate algae growth and ventilation issues
- Cold winters and freeze/thaw cycles that may expose weak spots around penetrations and valleys
- Tree cover and shaded roof slopes can trap moisture and shorten your roof’s lifespan
In a place like Lexington, the “right roof” is not only about color, it is about building a system that withstands local conditions and respects the home’s character.
At Valley Roofing & Exteriors, experience has taught us that we will not be the right fit for every homeowner, which is completely fine. What matters most is that you get a high-quality roof installed the right way, no matter who you hire. We put this list together to help cut through the noise and find a reputable professional you will feel confident in. Our goal is that by the end of this article, you will know how to compare the top roofing contractors in Lexington, including Valley Roofing & Exteriors, to ultimately determine which is the right fit for your project.
Disclaimer
Valley Roofing & Exteriors is included in this list and is a competitor with many of the companies mentioned. We apply the same evaluation criteria to every contractor, including ourselves. This article is meant to help Lexington homeowners start their search. It is not a guarantee of performance, and it is not a complete list of every qualified contractor. Availability, crews, pricing, and warranty offerings can change, so always get multiple estimates and confirm license/insurance and warranty terms in writing.
Which factors do we use to evaluate roofing contractors?
We evaluated established residential roofing contractors in the Lexington area using the following criteria:
- Years in business
- License and Insurance
- Certified Contractor
- Better Business Bureau (BBB) Rating and accreditation
- Google Review Rating
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees
- Established business location and marked vehicles
Certified Contractor
Leading roofing manufacturers, including GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning and TAMKO only certify contractors who satisfy strict requirements. These certifications often allow contractors to offer stronger warranties and greater long-term protection for you.
Better Business Bureau (BBB) Accreditation
The BBB accredits businesses that demonstrate trust, transparency, and ethical practices. Accredited companies must show they have been in business for over 6 months, meet licensing and ethical standards, including honest advertising, and provide responsive customer service.
Note: BBB accreditation requires annual dues, so not all reputable companies choose to become accredited.
Warranties and Workmanship Guarantees
Warranties and workmanship guarantees protect you in two ways: manufacturer warranties cover defects in roofing materials, while contractor workmanship guarantees cover issues caused by installation. Strong coverage and clear warranty terms in writing reduce your risk of leaks, premature failure, and unexpected repair costs down the road.
Who are the top residential roofers in Lexington?
Seaman Roofing – A family-owned roofing company with 30+ years of experience providing residential, commercial and industrial roofing solutions. They describe themselves as focused on quality craftsmanship and customer service.
- Years in business: 30
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2023
- Google Rating: 3.8 of 16 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: Not listed
- Established business location and marked vehicles: Not listed
Valley Roofing & Exteriors – With offices in Harrisonburg, Charlottesville, and Staunton, they provide roofing, gutters, skylights, windows, doors, siding, decking, and sunroom installations throughout the Shenandoah Valley. The company is an authorized dealer of Betterliving sunrooms, patios, and enclosed porches.
- Years in business: 22
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2013
- Google Rating: 4.9 of 767 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Donnie Higgins Siding & Home Remodeling – A remodeling contractor offering construction and remodeling services, kitchen and bathroom remodeling, patio and porch enclosures, custom decks, replacement windows and doors, roofing services, vinyl siding, sheds, garages, and home additions in Lexington, Virginia and the surrounding area.
- Years in business: 25
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Certified Contractor: Not listed
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2023
- Google Rating: 5.0 of 16 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: Not listed
- Established business location and marked vehicles: Not listed
220 Roofing & Restoration – Serves Lexington with residential roof repairs and full replacements, along with related exterior work such as storm-damage restoration. They are a Virginia-licensed contractor, which can be a helpful credibility check when you’re building your shortlist.
- Years in business: 2
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: Not accredited
- Google Rating: 4.9 of 77 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Baber Enterprises Roofing & More – A family-run contractor providing roofing and exterior services for residential and commercial properties. Based in Staunton, the company serves Broadway, Charlottesville, Crozet, Harrisonburg, Lexington, Mt. Crawford, Ruckersville and Waynesboro.
- Years in business: 40
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2022
- Google Rating: 4.8 of 152 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Did you do your due diligence?
No list can replace your own research. Look for roofers who:
- Do a real inspection (attic/ventilation + roof surface), not simply a driveway quote
- Provide a detailed written scope (underlayment, flashing, ventilation, disposal, decking terms)
- Can explain why their system fits your home (historic details, slopes, shade lines, drainage)
Is Valley Roofing & Exteriors the roofer for you?
With so many contractors to choose from, how do you know who is right for your roofing project? If you are looking for the cheapest price, a quick bargain, plan to move in the next few years, or you are flipping a house, another roofing contractor on this list may be a great match. On the other hand, Valley Roofing & Exteriors may be right for you if you value a trusted, full-service roofing and exterior partner focused on quality, reliable communication, and long-term peace of mind.
If you are still in research mode, you can check out our gallery to compare real roof styles, colors, and finished projects, without jumping into a sales conversation.
If you would like a no-pressure opinion on your Lexington roof, repair vs. replacement, material options, or what your estimate should include, Valley Roofing & Exteriors is here to help.
