Two questions homeowners consistently ask are: How do you compare to other contractors, and why should we choose Valley Roofing & Exteriors?
Choosing a roofing contractor is one of the most important decisions a homeowner can make. In Harrisonburg, roofs must withstand intense summer heat, heavy rain, snow, and strong winds, so experience, quality materials, and proper installation are non-negotiable.
Homeowners also face a variety of goals. Some need a fast, budget-friendly solution to satisfy an insurance claim or prepare a home for resale. Others are investing in their forever home and want the job done once, done right, with no corners cut.
The challenge is that many contractors sound similar on the surface. Nearly everyone claims to “do it all,” provides great service, and stands behind their work. In reality, every company has a niche, strengths and trade-offs that may or may not align with your priorities.
This guide is designed to help you cut through that noise. Rather than naming a single “best” roofer for everyone, we compare established residential roofing contractors serving the Harrisonburg area using clear, objective criteria.
This list is not exhaustive. It is intended to give you a strong starting point so you can make a confident, informed decision based on what matters most to you and your home.
Full disclaimer
Valley Roofing & Exteriors is included in this list and is a competitor with many of the companies mentioned. We apply the same evaluation criteria to every contractor, including ourselves. Our goal is that by the end of this article, you will know whether Valley Roofing & Exteriors is the right fit for your project.
Which factors do we use to evaluate roofing contractors?
We evaluated established residential roofing contractors in the Harrisonburg area using the following criteria:
- Years in business
- License and Insurance
- Certified Contractor
- Better Business Bureau (BBB) Rating and accreditation
- Google Review Rating
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees
- Established business location and marked vehicles
Certified Contractor
Leading roofing manufacturers, including GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning and TAMKO only certify contractors who satisfy strict requirements. These certifications often allow contractors to offer stronger warranties and greater long-term protection for you.
Better Business Bureau (BBB) Accreditation
The BBB accredits businesses that demonstrate trust, transparency, and ethical practices. Accredited companies must show they have been in business for over 6 months, meet licensing and ethical standards, including honest advertising, and provide responsive customer service.
Note: BBB accreditation requires annual dues, so not all reputable companies choose to become accredited.
Warranties and Workmanship Guarantees
Warranties and workmanship guarantees protect you in two ways: manufacturer warranties cover defects in roofing materials, while contractor workmanship guarantees cover issues caused by installation. Strong coverage and clear warranty terms in writing reduce your risk of leaks, premature failure, and unexpected repair costs down the road.
Who are the top residential roofers in Harrisonburg?
Shrocks Roofing – A roofing contractor based in Broadway, serving Harrisonburg, Weyers Cave and the surrounding Shenandoah Valley. The company specializes in residential and commercial roofing services, including shingle, slate, and metal roof installation, repair, and replacement. While their Google rating is low, Shrocks Roofing has a long-standing history and strong warranty offerings, which may appeal to homeowners prioritizing experience and value.
- Years in business: 30 years
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2015
- Google Rating: 2.6 of 5 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Senger Roofing LLC – A local roofing contractor in Harrisonburg, serving the Shenandoah Valley. The company specializes in residential and commercial roofing, siding, windows, and gutter services.
- Years in business: 35
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: Not accredited
- Google Rating: 4.8 of 100 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Valley Roofing & Exteriors – With offices in Harrisonburg, Charlottesville, and Staunton, they provide roofing, gutters, skylights, windows, doors, siding, decking, and sunroom installations throughout the Shenandoah Valley. The company is an authorized dealer of Betterliving sunrooms, patios, and enclosed porches.
- Years in business: 22
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2013
- Google Rating: 4.9 of 767 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Helmuth Roofing – A roofing contractor based in Harrisonburg, serving the surrounding Shenandoah Valley, including Staunton, Charlottesville and Winchester. The company offers residential and commercial roof repair and replacement, asphalt and metal roofing, gutters, skylights, and insulation.
- Years in business: 6
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: Not accredited
- Google Rating: 4.9 of 84 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Baber Enterprises Roofing & More – A family-run contractor providing roofing and exterior services for residential and commercial properties. Based in Staunton, the company serves Broadway, Charlottesville, Crozet, Harrisonburg, Lexington, Mt. Crawford, Ruckersville and Waynesboro.
- Years in business: 40
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2022
- Google Rating: 4.8 of 152 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Highest Roofing & Exteriors – A local family-operated contractor offering roofing, siding, and gutter services. The company services Harrisonburg, Weyers Cave, Staunton, Verona and Luray.
- Years in business: 6
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2025
- Google Rating: 5.0 of 144 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Holloway Roofing – A local roofer known for residential and commercial services. The company serves Harrisonburg and surrounding communities from its Weyers Cave base.
- Years in business: 9
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2023
- Google Rating: 5.0 of 978 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Cenvar Roofing – A large regional roofing and solar company serving multiple states, including Virginia and West Virginia. With thousands of reviews, the company offers roofing, gutters, and general contracting services for homeowners.
- Years in business: 13
- License and Insurance: ✓
- Top Certified Contractor: ✓
- BBB Rating: A+ accredited since 2016
- Google Rating: 4.9 of 3,125 reviews
- Warranties and workmanship guarantees: ✓
- Established business location and marked vehicles: ✓
Did you do your due diligence?
No “best of” list can replace your own research. There are several critical factors only you can evaluate, including how a contractor communicates, the professionalism of their process and how confident you feel in their team. Here are three areas that matter most:
- Customer service: If a contractor is difficult to reach when you are asking for information or a quote, it rarely improves once work begins. Clear, timely communication is a strong indicator of how the job will be managed.
- Installation quality: Roofing materials rarely fail on their own. Most problems come down to workmanship and installation. How your roof is installed ultimately determines how long it will last.
- Trustworthiness: Roofing consistently ranks high on the BBB’s list of consumer complaints. Unfortunately, stories of deposits taken and contractors disappearing are all too common. Verifying credibility is essential; reviews and business standing are a good place to start.
Is Valley Roofing & Exteriors the roofer for you?
Whether you need a full roof replacement or an emergency repair, take the time to research, compare, and choose a contractor you trust. Making the right decision now can save you years of stress and costly repairs.
So how do you know if Valley Roofing & Exteriors is right for your roofing project? If you are looking for the cheapest price, a quick bargain, plan to move in the next few years, or you are flipping a house, another roofing contractor may be a better match. Valley Roofing & Exteriors may be right for you if you value a trusted, full-service roofing and exterior partner focused on quality, reliable communication, and long-term peace of mind.
Fill out the contact form to speak with a roofing professional today.
Contact Us for a Free Roofing Estimate.
